Stack It: lesson plan

Students stack real-sized books, mugs and apples from a swinging crane, switch on plumb lines to see the centre of mass, and use what they find to explain why towers fall, why wide bases help and how a stack of books can hang right off a table.

Ages
9–14 (grades 4–9)
Time
50 minutes
Subject
Physics: centre of mass, stability and balance
You need
Devices with a browser (one per pair), five identical books or rulers per group, a table edge, string and a small weight for a plumb line

Open Stack It Jump to the quiz

Learning objectives

By the end of the lesson, students can:

Key vocabulary

Centre of mass
The point where all the mass of an object can be thought of as concentrated. For a uniform book it is at the centre.
Base of support
The area of contact underneath an object, or the area enclosed by its contact points.
Stable
Able to return to its position after a small push. Something is more stable if it can tilt further before toppling.
Moment (turning effect)
Force × perpendicular distance from a pivot. When an object’s weight acts outside its base, it makes a moment that tips it over.
Plumb line
A weight on a string. It hangs straight down, so it shows the vertical line through a point.
Overhang
How far something sticks out past the edge of what supports it.

Background for the teacher

Every object in Stack It is a rigid body with a real size, mass and friction, and the engine resolves contacts many times a second with small impulses (the sequential impulse method used in many game engines). The rule that decides everything is the stability rule: a stack stands while the centre of mass of everything above each level lies over the surface supporting it. The plumb button (P) draws these lines, and the turn button (R) turns an object a quarter turn.

Tall, thin objects tip at small angles. A book standing on its end, 3.5 cm thick and 24 cm tall, topples once tilted past about arctan(3.5 ÷ 24) ≈ 8°, while a cube can tilt to 45°. Dropped objects also obey free fall: from 10 cm, a dictionary and an eraser both land after about 0.14 s. The puzzle Beyond the edge uses the block-stacking problem: with one book per level, the top book can overhang by ½ a book length, the next by ¼, then ⅙ and ⅛, so the total overhang is ½(1 + ½ + ⅓ + ¼ + …). With four books that is 25/24 ≈ 1.04 book lengths, so the top book is completely past the edge. The series grows without limit, though slowly. The Leaning Tower of Pisa still leans about 3.97° after engineers reduced its tilt from 5.5° between 1993 and 2001.

Warm-up (5 minutes)

Activity with the game

  1. Pairs open Stack It and play First stack and Mug on top. Tap, click or press Space to drop each object from the crane. Note how a drop off-centre makes the tower lean.
  2. Switch on the plumb lines (P). Build a tower and watch the lines. Pairs record what the plumb line shows just before a tower falls (it moves past the edge of the object underneath).
  3. Play Stand it up, using the turn button (R). Compare a book lying flat with one standing on its end, and explain which is easier to knock over using the words centre of mass and base.
  4. Play Leaning tower: lean six cubes more than Pisa’s 3.97° without falling. Pairs explain how far they could push the lean and what limited it.
  5. Play Beyond the edge. Then repeat it with real books or rulers on a table: place the top book half its length over the one below, the next a quarter, then a sixth, then an eighth. Measure the total overhang and compare with 25/24 of a book length.
  6. Regroup: pairs share one rule for building a tall, stable tower and the evidence from the game that supports it.

Discussion questions

Why did your tower fall even though every object looked balanced on the one below?
Show a model answerWhat matters is the combined centre of mass of everything above each level. Small offsets add up, so the centre of mass of the top few objects together can move past the edge of the object supporting them, even if each pair looks fine.
Why should heavy, flat objects go at the bottom?
Show a model answerThey lower the overall centre of mass and give a wide base, so the tower can tilt further before its centre of mass moves outside the base. Light, round things high up add little mass and so shift the centre of mass less.
How can the top book hang completely past the table edge without falling?
Show a model answerEach book only needs the centre of mass of all the books above it to lie over the book below. Working down from the top, the overhangs can be ½, ¼, ⅙ and ⅛ of a book length, which add up to just over one full book length.
A book on its end tips at about 8°, a cube at 45°. Why?
Show a model answerAn object tips when its centre of mass moves past the edge of its base. For a tall, thin book the centre of mass is high above a narrow base, so only a small tilt carries it past the edge. A cube’s centre of mass is low compared with its base width.

Common misconceptions

Heavy objects are always more stable.
Stability depends on where the centre of mass is compared with the base. A heavy, tall, thin object can fall more easily than a light, wide one.
The centre of mass must be inside the object.
It can be in empty space, as with a ring, a mug or a boomerang. For a stack, the combined centre of mass can sit in the air past the table edge.

Quick quiz

  1. A stack stays standing as long as…

    1. it is made of heavy objects
    2. its centre of mass is over its base
    3. it is shorter than 1 m
    4. it is not moving
    Answer

    B. If the centre of mass moves outside the base, gravity makes a turning effect that tips it over.

  2. Which shape can tilt furthest before it falls?

    1. A book on its end
    2. A tall bottle
    3. A cube
    4. A pencil standing up
    Answer

    C. A cube’s centre of mass is low compared with its wide base, so it can tilt to 45°.

  3. What does a plumb line show?

    1. The horizontal
    2. The vertical straight down from a point
    3. The mass of an object
    4. The friction on a surface
    Answer

    B. A hanging weight points straight down, so it shows where the centre of mass is above the base.

  4. With one book per level, the overhangs are ½, ¼, ⅙ and ⅛ of a book. What is the total for four books?

    1. About ½ a book
    2. About ¾ of a book
    3. Just over 1 book
    4. Exactly 2 books
    Answer

    C. ½ + ¼ + ⅙ + ⅛ = 25/24, just over one book length.

  5. Why does putting heavy objects low make a tower more stable?

    1. It lowers the centre of mass
    2. It makes the tower lighter
    3. It increases friction
    4. It makes the objects fall slower
    Answer

    A. A lower centre of mass needs a bigger tilt before it moves outside the base.

  6. How much does the Leaning Tower of Pisa lean today?

    1. About 0.5°
    2. About 4°
    3. About 15°
    4. About 45°
    Answer

    B. About 3.97°, after work between 1993 and 2001 reduced it from 5.5°.

Going further

Calculators for this lesson

Curriculum links

The science in this plan matches the notes and sources under Stack It. Free to use and adapt for teaching. Ideas or corrections: hello@notebookfun.com.