Will It Hold?: lesson plan
Students design bridges on graph paper, watch the load flow through every member as a truck, bus, elephant and train drive across, and use the results to explain tension and compression, why triangles make rigid structures and why long struts buckle.
- Ages
- 11–16 (grades 6–10)
- Time
- 60 minutes (or two 40-minute sessions)
- Subject
- Physics and engineering: structures, tension and compression
- You need
- Devices with a browser (one per pair), drinking straws or lolly sticks, paper fasteners or tape, string, a small weight (a pencil case works)
Open Will It Hold? Jump to the quiz
Learning objectives
By the end of the lesson, students can:
- Identify members in tension (being pulled) and compression (being pushed) in a loaded truss.
- Explain why a triangle is rigid when its joints are pinned, but a square is not.
- Explain buckling, and use Euler’s rule that the buckling load falls with the square of a strut’s length.
- Use an engineering design cycle: build, test, find the first member to fail, improve, and balance strength against cost.
Key vocabulary
- Tension
- A pulling force that stretches a member. Rope and cables can only carry tension.
- Compression
- A pushing force that squashes a member. Arches carry their load in compression.
- Truss
- A frame made of straight members joined into triangles, so each member only pushes or pulls.
- Strut and tie
- A strut is a member in compression; a tie is a member in tension.
- Buckling
- Sudden sideways bending of a long, slender member under compression, at a load far below what would crush it.
- Load
- The forces a structure must carry, including its own weight and the vehicles crossing it.
Background for the teacher
In Will It Hold?, every member is a stiff spring with real mass, pinned at its joints and solved with position-based dynamics (XPBD) at 2,400 steps a second, so members can only pull or push along their length, never bend. That is exactly the simplification engineers use to analyse a truss by hand. Members glow blue when relaxed and red near their limit. Wood holds about 60 kN in tension and about 55 kN in compression; steel is four times as strong but nearly four times the cost and three times the weight; rope carries tension only and goes slack if pushed. The paper truck weighs 2 tonnes (about 19.6 kN of weight), the school bus 8 tonnes and the train 12 tonnes.
A square frame with pinned corners folds flat, but a triangle cannot change shape without changing a side’s length, so a truss turns loads into pure tension and compression. In a Pratt truss (1844) the diagonals are in tension and the verticals in compression; the Howe truss (1840) is the reverse; the Warren truss (1848) uses equal triangles. Long struts fail early by buckling: Euler showed in 1744 that the buckling load falls with the square of length, so a 4 m strut takes only a quarter of the load of a 2 m one. Stars reward finishing under budget, spending 80% or less, and keeping every member below 85% of its limit, which pull against each other as they do in real engineering.
Warm-up (5 minutes)
- Make a square and a triangle from four and three straws joined with paper fasteners at the corners. Ask pupils to push on a corner of each. Which keeps its shape, and why?
- Push gently on the ends of a long and a short piece of spaghetti or a ruler. Which bends sideways first? Introduce the word buckling.
Activity with the game
- Pairs open Will It Hold? and play First crossing and Triangles. Choose a material, drag from a red bolt or joint to a grid point to place a member, then press Test. Note how a plain road sags and how wooden triangles fix it.
- During a test, press S for slow motion and watch the colours. Pairs sketch their bridge and label each member T (tension) or C (compression), using what they see and the Pratt truss diagram on the game page.
- Play Underneath and The arch. Pairs compare a truss hung below the road with an arch pushing up from below, and explain which members are pushed and which are pulled.
- Play Rope trick. Pairs explain why rope works for the hangers but fails as a strut.
- Design cycle: on The school bus or Elephant walk, each pair records cost, the first member to turn red and the change they made, for at least three tests. They aim for all three stars.
- Buckling test: in any level, replace one long wooden strut with two shorter ones braced at the middle. Pairs record whether its colour (stress) changes and explain using Euler’s rule.
- Regroup: each pair shows its cheapest working design and explains one trade-off it made between cost and safety.
Discussion questions
- Why are triangles used in bridges and cranes?
Show a model answer
A triangle cannot change shape unless one of its sides changes length. With pinned joints, any other polygon can fold. So a frame of triangles stays rigid, and each member only carries tension or compression, which materials handle well.- Why did a long wooden strut fail when the force in it was below wood’s crushing limit?
Show a model answer
It buckled. Long, thin members in compression bend sideways at a much lower load than would crush them. The buckling load falls with the square of the length, so halving the length makes a strut four times harder to buckle.- Why can rope be used for the hangers of a suspension bridge but not for a strut?
Show a model answer
Rope is strong in tension but has no stiffness when pushed: it simply goes slack. Hangers are pulled by the road hanging below them, so rope is ideal. A strut is pushed, so it needs a stiff material like wood or steel.- Why does a deeper truss carry more load?
Show a model answer
The top and bottom chords form a pair of forces that resist the bending effect of the load. The further apart they are, the smaller each force needs to be. Doubling the depth roughly halves the force in the chords.- Why is it hard to get the “below 85% of limit” star and the “80% of budget” star together?
Show a model answer
Using less material saves money but makes each member carry more of the load, closer to its limit. Adding material lowers the stress but costs more. Real engineers face the same trade-off and use safety factors to decide how much margin they need.
Common misconceptions
- A thicker or heavier bridge is always stronger.
- Extra material also adds weight that the bridge must carry. Good design puts material where the forces are and uses shapes, like triangles and arches, that carry load efficiently.
- Every part of a bridge is being squashed by the weight on it.
- Many members are being pulled. In a truss, some members are in tension and others in compression, and in a suspension bridge the main cables are entirely in tension.
- The Tacoma Narrows Bridge collapsed because of simple resonance.
- It failed through aeroelastic flutter, a self-feeding twisting motion between the wind and the slender deck, in a wind of only about 64 km/h on 7 November 1940.
Quick quiz
A rope in a bridge can carry…
- only compression
- only tension
- both tension and compression
- neither
Answer
B. Rope can pull but goes slack if pushed.
Why is a triangle rigid?
- It has the fewest corners
- Its shape cannot change without a side changing length
- Its angles add up to 180°
- It is the lightest shape
Answer
B. With pinned joints, any polygon with more sides can fold; a triangle cannot.
A 2 m strut buckles at 40 kN. Roughly what load buckles an identical 4 m strut?
- 80 kN
- 40 kN
- 20 kN
- 10 kN
Answer
D. Buckling load falls with length squared: double the length gives a quarter of the load.
An arch carries its load mainly in…
- tension
- compression
- bending
- torsion
Answer
B. Hooke’s hanging chain turned upside down gives a shape in pure compression.
What is the weight of a 2,000 kg truck? (g = 9.81 N/kg)
- 204 N
- 2,000 N
- About 19,600 N
- About 200,000 N
Answer
C. W = mg = 2,000 × 9.81 ≈ 19,600 N, or 19.6 kN.
In a Pratt truss, the diagonals are in…
- compression
- tension
- no force at all
- bending
Answer
B. Pratt diagonals slope towards the middle and are pulled, so they can be slim.
Going further
- Build a straw bridge across a 30 cm gap using no more than 20 straws. Test it with weights, record the load at failure and identify which member failed first.
- Calculate: use the force calculator to find the weight of each vehicle in the game (2, 5, 8 and 12 tonnes) in kilonewtons.
- Research: compare the Akashi Kaikyō Bridge (1,991 m main span) with the 1915 Çanakkale Bridge (2,023 m). How do suspension bridges reach such lengths?
Calculators for this lesson
Curriculum links
- NGSS MS-ETS1-3: analyze data from tests to determine similarities and differences among several design solutions to identify the best characteristics of each that can be combined into a new solution to better meet the criteria for success.
- NGSS MS-ETS1-4: develop a model to generate data for iterative testing and modification of a proposed object, tool, or process such that an optimal design can be achieved.
- England National Curriculum, KS3 Physics: forces associated with deforming objects; stretching and squashing.
The science in this plan matches the notes and sources under Will It Hold?. Free to use and adapt for teaching. Ideas or corrections: hello@notebookfun.com.