Murmuration: lesson plan

Pupils play the falcon hunting thousands of starlings, then open the flock’s rule dials and break it. They discover that nobody leads a murmuration: each bird follows three simple rules using its seven nearest neighbours, and the swirling whole emerges from that. They connect it to why grouping helps prey survive.

Ages
11–16 (grades 6–10)
Time
50 minutes
Subject
Biology: animal behaviour, predators and emergent patterns
You need
Devices with a browser (one per pair), a short video of a real starling murmuration, open floor space for the playground flocking game

Open Murmuration Jump to the quiz

Learning objectives

By the end of the lesson, students can:

Key vocabulary

Murmuration
A huge flock of starlings swirling over its roost at dusk, mostly in autumn and winter.
Emergent behaviour
A large-scale pattern that arises from many individuals following simple local rules, with no leader or plan.
Separation, alignment, cohesion
The three boids rules: do not crowd your neighbours, match their heading, and move towards the group.
Topological interaction
Reacting to a fixed number of nearest neighbours (about seven in starlings), however near or far they are.
Predator / prey
An animal that hunts (here the peregrine falcon) and the animal it hunts (the starling).
Dilution and confusion effects
In a big group, each individual is less likely to be the one caught, and a predator finds it hard to pick out and track one target.

Background for the teacher

Common starlings gather in flocks of a few hundred to hundreds of thousands over winter roosts such as the Somerset Levels, Rome and Denmark’s Wadden Sea. In 2008 Ballerini and colleagues filmed flocks in Rome with several cameras, rebuilt each bird’s 3D position and found that each starling responds to about six or seven nearest neighbours regardless of distance. This topological rule keeps a flock together as it stretches. Later work (Young and colleagues, 2013) suggested seven is a good trade-off between reaching agreement and the effort of paying attention. Cavagna and colleagues (2010) showed that a change of direction is correlated across the whole flock however large it is, which is why a falcon’s attack on one edge can send a dark ripple across the flock in about a second.

The game uses Craig Reynolds’ 1986 boids rules with only the nearest neighbours. Its “rules” tab has four dials: stay apart, match neighbours, stick together (each 0 to 2, default 1) and neighbours each bird watches (default 7, marked “real starlings”). A 2017 citizen-science study found murmurations were bigger and lasted longer when a predator such as a peregrine or sparrowhawk was present, supporting the safety-in-numbers explanation.

Warm-up (5 minutes)

Activity with the game

  1. Pairs open Murmuration. One pupil plays the falcon for two minutes: move the pointer near the flock to scare birds, then click or tap to dive. The other watches how the panic spreads and describes it.
  2. Work through the evening’s goals list, such as “Scare them 10 times”, “Split the flock in two” or “Punch a hole: make a ring”. Note which tactics split the flock and which only dent it.
  3. Open the rules tab. Change one dial at a time to its minimum and then its maximum, leaving the others at default. Record what each extreme does to the flock in a table: stay apart, match neighbours, stick together.
  4. Now set neighbours each bird watches to 1. What happens? Slowly raise it back to 7 (“real starlings”). At what value does the flock first hold together? (If “Break it” and “Mend it” are on tonight’s list, this ticks them off.)
  5. Pairs write a short explanation: why does no single bird need to know the shape of the whole flock?
  6. Class round-up: compare tables. Agree on one sentence for what each rule does, and link to the dilution and confusion effects: why might a falcon find it harder to catch a bird in a well-mixed flock?

Discussion questions

If no bird is in charge, how does the whole flock turn together?
Show a model answerEach bird copies the heading of its nearest neighbours. A turn by a few birds is copied by their neighbours, then by theirs, so the change ripples across the flock in a fraction of a second.
What happened when you set the neighbours dial to 1, and why?
Show a model answerThe flock broke into small groups that drifted apart. With only one neighbour, information cannot spread far, so distant parts of the flock stop agreeing on direction.
Why might a flock of thousands be safer for each starling than flying alone?
Show a model answerA falcon can only catch one bird at a time, so each bird’s chance of being the one is diluted. The dense, shifting crowd also confuses the predator, making it hard to lock onto a single target. More eyes also spot danger earlier.
What would happen with only the “stick together” rule and no “stay apart”?
Show a model answerBirds would crowd into a tight clump and collide. Separation keeps a safe gap; the balance between the two rules gives the flock its density.
Where else do we see emergent behaviour from simple rules?
Show a model answerFish shoals, ant trails, traffic jams that move backwards, crowds leaving a stadium, and computer animation of crowds and herds in films, which uses boids-style rules.

Common misconceptions

A leader bird at the front decides where the flock goes.
There is no leader. Patterns emerge from every bird reacting to its nearest few neighbours, and any bird can start a turn.
Each bird watches every bird within a certain distance.
Real starlings track a fixed number of neighbours, about six or seven, however spread out the flock is. That is why flocks hold together while they stretch and squeeze.
Murmurations happen to attack predators.
Starlings cannot fight off a falcon. The best-supported explanation is defensive: safety in numbers while gathering to roost.

Quick quiz

  1. Which rule stops birds in a flock from crashing into each other?

    1. Alignment
    2. Cohesion
    3. Separation
    4. Migration
    Answer

    C. Separation (“stay apart”) makes each bird keep a gap from its neighbours.

  2. About how many nearest neighbours does a real starling react to?

    1. 1
    2. 6 or 7
    3. About 50
    4. Every bird in the flock
    Answer

    B. Ballerini and colleagues (2008) found each starling responds to about six or seven nearest neighbours.

  3. What does “emergent behaviour” mean?

    1. Behaviour in an emergency
    2. A pattern planned by a leader
    3. A large pattern that arises from simple local rules
    4. Behaviour that is learned from parents
    Answer

    C. The flock’s shape is not planned by anyone. It emerges from many birds each following simple rules.

  4. Which is the best-supported reason starlings murmurate?

    1. To keep warm in the air
    2. To find food in the sky
    3. To scare away other birds
    4. Safety in numbers against predators
    Answer

    D. A 2017 study found murmurations were bigger and lasted longer when a predator was present, fitting the safety-in-numbers idea.

  5. What does the “match neighbours” (alignment) rule do?

    1. Makes birds fly the same direction as those nearby
    2. Keeps birds apart
    3. Pulls birds to the centre of the whole flock
    4. Makes birds land
    Answer

    A. Alignment turns each bird towards the average heading of its neighbours.

Going further

Curriculum links

The science in this plan matches the notes and sources under Murmuration. Free to use and adapt for teaching. Ideas or corrections: hello@notebookfun.com.