How Precise Are You?: lesson plan

Pupils sit ten tiny precision tests (stop a hidden timer at 10 seconds, tap the exact middle of a line, draw a right angle, remember a colour) and turn their results into data. They learn the difference between accuracy and precision, how to calculate absolute and percentage error, and why repeating a measurement helps.

Ages
10–14 (grades 5–9)
Time
50 minutes
Subject
Maths and science: measurement, error and accuracy
You need
Devices with a browser (one per pupil or pair), results sheet, calculators, optional stopwatches and rulers

Open How Precise Are You? Jump to the quiz

Learning objectives

By the end of the lesson, students can:

Key vocabulary

True value
The value you are aiming for, such as exactly 10.00 seconds or exactly 90°.
Absolute error
How far a result is from the true value, ignoring the sign. Stopping at 10.43 s when aiming for 10 s is an error of 0.43 s.
Percentage error
Absolute error divided by the true value, times 100. An error of 0.43 s on 10 s is 4.3%.
Accuracy
How close a result (or the average of several) is to the true value.
Precision
How close repeated results are to each other, whether or not they are near the true value.
Random error
Unpredictable scatter that pushes results sometimes high, sometimes low. Averaging repeats reduces its effect.
Systematic error
A consistent bias in the same direction, such as always stopping early. Averaging does not remove it.

Background for the teacher

The game gives ten short tests: stop a hidden timer at a target number of seconds (the dial is covered after 3 s), tap the middle of a line, mark a fraction of a line, draw an angle, draw a straight line between dots, remember a colour’s hue, estimate a number of dots seen for one second, keep a beat after four clicks, stop a fast moving bar at a mark, and match two lengths. Each error is measured exactly, in milliseconds, pixels, degrees or hue, and converted to a score out of 100, so a perfect paper is 1,000. Three papers (A, B, C) with different targets rotate each time.

The tests show a useful pattern from psychology: we are good at comparing (halving a line) and poor at absolute judgements (holding a colour in memory, or 10 seconds without a clock). For quantities seen at a glance, errors grow roughly in proportion to the size, so a guess for 120 dots is usually further off in dots than a guess for 30, though the percentage error can be similar. Counted time drifts by several percent. The game compares your paper with 5,000 simulated people; in that model the median is about 660 and roughly one in ten passes 820. Nothing is collected, so classes can compare freely.

Warm-up (5 minutes)

Activity with the game

  1. Each pupil opens How Precise Are You? and sits one full paper. After each test, they copy the exact error the game shows (for example “off by 0.43 seconds” or “off 3.5°”) onto their results sheet, as well as the score.
  2. For the three tests with a clear true value in everyday units (the seconds timer, the angle and the beat), pupils calculate the percentage error. For the timer, use error ÷ target × 100.
  3. Repeat the timer test five times by retaking papers (the targets change between papers A, B and C, so record the target each time). Calculate the mean error with sign (early is negative, late positive) and the range.
  4. Pupils decide: is their timing more limited by random error (results scattered both sides) or systematic error (consistently early or late)? What would they change to improve accuracy, and what to improve precision?
  5. Pool the class’s results for the dots test on the board: target number and guess. Plot guess against target. Does the spread get bigger as the number grows?
  6. Finish by comparing which of the ten tests had the biggest average percentage error across the class, and discuss why the brain finds that one hardest.

Discussion questions

Ben stopped the timer at 9.1 s, 9.2 s, 9.1 s and 9.2 s, aiming for 10 s. Was he accurate, precise, both or neither?
Show a model answerPrecise, because his results are very close together, but not accurate, because they are all about 0.85 s early. That is a systematic error: he counts slightly too fast.
Why does averaging several attempts help with some errors but not others?
Show a model answerRandom errors push results both high and low, so they partly cancel in the mean. A systematic error pushes every result the same way, so the average is just as biased.
Why is tapping the middle of a line easier than remembering a colour?
Show a model answerFor the middle you can compare the two halves directly while you look. For the colour you must store an exact value in memory, and memory drifts toward familiar “best examples” of colours.
An error of 3 dots on a guess of 30 and an error of 12 dots on 120. Which guess was better?
Show a model answerBoth are 10% percentage errors, so they are equally good relative to the size. Percentage error lets you compare results of very different sizes.
Where do scientists or professionals need very precise timing or judgement?
Show a model answerSprint timing (hand timing is less reliable than electronic timing because of reaction time), musicians keeping tempo, surgeons, pilots judging distances, and lab measurements where they repeat readings and report a mean.

Common misconceptions

Accurate and precise mean the same thing.
Accuracy is about closeness to the true value; precision is about how close repeated results are to each other. You can be precise but wrong.
If I repeat a measurement enough times, the average will always be right.
Repeats only reduce random error. A systematic bias, such as a slow stopwatch or always counting too fast, stays in the average.
A bigger error in units always means a worse result.
It depends on the size of the thing measured. Percentage error compares results fairly: 1 cm off over 1 m is better than 1 mm off over 2 cm.

Quick quiz

  1. You aim for 10.00 s and stop at 10.40 s. What is the percentage error?

    1. 0.4%
    2. 4%
    3. 40%
    4. 10.4%
    Answer

    B. 0.40 ÷ 10.00 × 100 = 4%.

  2. Four arrows land close together but far from the bullseye. They are…

    1. Accurate and precise
    2. Accurate but not precise
    3. Precise but not accurate
    4. Neither
    Answer

    C. Tightly grouped means precise; far from the centre means not accurate.

  3. Which kind of error can averaging repeated results reduce?

    1. Systematic error
    2. Random error
    3. Both equally
    4. Neither
    Answer

    B. Random errors scatter both ways and partly cancel. A systematic error biases every result the same way.

  4. You draw an angle of 86° when aiming for 90°. What is the absolute error?

    1. 4°
    2. −4°
    3. 4.4%
    4. 86°
    Answer

    A. Absolute error is the size of the difference, ignoring sign: 90 − 86 = 4°.

  5. Five timer attempts: 9.6, 9.8, 10.1, 9.7 and 9.8 s. What is the mean?

    1. 9.7 s
    2. 9.8 s
    3. 10.0 s
    4. 9.9 s
    Answer

    B. (9.6 + 9.8 + 10.1 + 9.7 + 9.8) ÷ 5 = 49.0 ÷ 5 = 9.8 s.

  6. A stopwatch that always starts 0.2 s late causes what kind of error?

    1. Random error
    2. Percentage error
    3. No error
    4. Systematic error
    Answer

    D. It shifts every reading by the same amount in the same direction.

Going further

Calculators for this lesson

Curriculum links

The science in this plan matches the notes and sources under How Precise Are You?. Free to use and adapt for teaching. Ideas or corrections: hello@notebookfun.com.