The Harmonograph: lesson plan

Students draw figures with a virtual harmonograph, time a real string pendulum, and discover that a pendulum’s length alone sets its rhythm. Simple frequency ratios like 2:1 and 3:2 give closed, symmetrical drawings, the same ratios that sound harmonious in music.

Ages
11–16 (grades 6–10)
Time
50 minutes
Subject
Physics and maths: pendulums, frequency and ratio
You need
Devices with a browser (one per pair), string, a metre rule, a stopwatch and a small mass (or a bunch of keys) per group, calculators

Open The Harmonograph Jump to the quiz

Learning objectives

By the end of the lesson, students can:

Key vocabulary

Period (T)
The time for one complete back-and-forth swing, in seconds.
Frequency (f)
The number of complete swings per second, in hertz (Hz). f = 1 ÷ T.
Oscillation
A repeated back-and-forth motion about a central position.
Damping
The gradual loss of energy from an oscillation, mostly to friction and air resistance, so the swings get smaller.
Ratio
A comparison of two quantities, such as 3:2. In the harmonograph it compares the two pendulums’ frequencies.
Musical interval
The pitch gap between two notes. An octave is a 2:1 frequency ratio and a perfect fifth is 3:2.

Background for the teacher

For small swings, a simple pendulum’s period is T = 2π√(L/g), with g = 9.81 m/s². It does not depend on the mass of the bob, and barely on the amplitude: a 15° swing takes under half a percent longer than a tiny one. A 1.00 m pendulum has a period of 2.01 s; a 0.25 m pendulum, 1.00 s. Because T grows with the square root of L, frequency is proportional to 1/√L, so doubling the frequency needs a quarter of the length, and a 3:2 frequency ratio needs a 4:9 length ratio (for example 1.00 m and 0.44 m).

In the game one pendulum moves the pen left and right, the other forward and back. The trace is the sum of two damped sine waves. With a simple ratio the pen returns to almost the same point every few swings and the figure closes up; a slightly-off ratio makes it slowly rotate, and an irrational ratio never repeats. Friction makes every figure spiral inward and stop after about a minute. These are damped Lissajous figures (Lissajous, 1857); Hugh Blackburn is usually credited with an early harmonograph in 1844. The same ratios appear in music: 2:1 is an octave, 3:2 a fifth, 4:3 a fourth, 5:4 a major third.

Warm-up (5 minutes)

Activity with the game

  1. Real pendulum first (10 minutes): groups time 10 swings of a 1.00 m string pendulum, then 0.25 m, then 1.00 m with double the mass, then 1.00 m with a bigger swing. Divide by 10 to get each period. Which change mattered?
  2. Pairs open The Harmonograph, set the two sliders to the same length and press Swing again. Describe the figure (a line, ellipse or circle depending on the start) and why it does not spiral into anything fancier.
  3. Press Nice ratios to jump through the simple intervals. For each, record the two lengths shown, the ratio of lengths, the interval named in the HUD, and a quick sketch. Check: is the length ratio the square of the frequency ratio, flipped?
  4. Now set a ratio by hand that is just off a nice one (nudge one slider a little). Watch the figure slowly rotate and listen to the two notes when the slider moves. Link this to the out-of-tune wobble from the warm-up.
  5. Challenge: press the star button for a target drawing. Pairs must predict the frequency ratio from the shape (count the lobes along each edge) before touching the sliders, then tune to match it.
  6. Creative finish: layer two figures with different pen colours, turn on Table spins for a third pendulum, and save a print with the download button for a class display labelled with the ratios used.

Discussion questions

Why did doubling the mass make no difference to the period?
Show a model answerA heavier bob needs a bigger force to accelerate it, but gravity also pulls on it with a proportionally bigger force. The two effects cancel, so the period depends only on length and g.
Why does the pendulum have to be four times shorter, not two times shorter, to swing twice as fast?
Show a model answerThe period is proportional to the square root of the length. To halve √L you have to divide L by four.
Why do simple ratios like 3:2 make neat, closed figures?
Show a model answerAfter 3 swings of one pendulum and 2 of the other, both are back where they started, so the pen retraces almost the same path. With a messy ratio the two never line up, so the curve keeps wandering into new places.
Why does every figure spiral inward and finish?
Show a model answerFriction and air resistance take energy out of the swings (damping), so the amplitude shrinks a little every swing while the period stays almost the same.
What is the link between neat figures and pleasant musical intervals?
Show a model answerBoth come from simple frequency ratios. Two notes in a 3:2 ratio have waves that line up every few cycles, which sounds smooth; the harmonograph shows the same lining-up as a closed shape.

Common misconceptions

A heavier pendulum swings faster (or slower).
For a simple pendulum, mass has no effect on the period. Only length and gravitational field strength matter.
Bigger swings take longer because the bob goes further.
The bob also moves faster on a bigger swing. For swings under about 15° the period changes by less than half a percent.
Half the length means twice the frequency.
Frequency goes with 1/√L, so half the length gives about 1.41 times the frequency. A quarter of the length doubles it.

Quick quiz

  1. What is the period of a pendulum 1.00 m long on Earth?

    1. About 1.0 s
    2. About 2.0 s
    3. About 3.1 s
    4. About 9.8 s
    Answer

    B. T = 2π√(1.00 ÷ 9.81) ≈ 2.01 s.

  2. You want a pendulum with twice the frequency of a 1.00 m pendulum. How long should it be?

    1. 2.00 m
    2. 0.50 m
    3. 0.25 m
    4. 0.71 m
    Answer

    C. Frequency is proportional to 1/√L, so a quarter of the length doubles the frequency.

  3. Which change would make a pendulum swing more slowly?

    1. A heavier bob
    2. A longer string
    3. A smaller swing
    4. A shinier bob
    Answer

    B. Period increases with the square root of length. Mass and small changes in swing size make almost no difference.

  4. A 3:2 frequency ratio is which musical interval?

    1. Octave
    2. Perfect fourth
    3. Major third
    4. Perfect fifth
    Answer

    D. 2:1 is an octave, 3:2 a perfect fifth, 4:3 a perfect fourth and 5:4 a major third.

  5. Why does a harmonograph drawing slowly shrink toward the centre?

    1. Gravity gets weaker
    2. The strings stretch
    3. Damping removes energy from the swings
    4. The frequency keeps doubling
    Answer

    C. Friction and air resistance take energy away, so the amplitude decreases while the period stays nearly constant.

  6. Two pendulums are 0.81 m and 0.36 m long. What is their frequency ratio?

    1. 9:4
    2. 3:2
    3. 2:1
    4. 81:36
    Answer

    B. √0.81 = 0.9 and √0.36 = 0.6. Frequency goes with 1/√L, so the ratio is 0.9 : 0.6 = 3:2, with the short one faster.

Going further

Calculators for this lesson

Curriculum links

The science in this plan matches the notes and sources under The Harmonograph. Free to use and adapt for teaching. Ideas or corrections: hello@notebookfun.com.