Grow a Snowflake: lesson plan

Students steer a growing ice crystal through layers of cloud, then use the shapes they grow to work out the rule Ukichiro Nakaya discovered in the 1930s: the temperature and dampness of the air decide what a snowflake looks like.

Ages
9–14 (grades 4–9)
Time
45 minutes
Subject
Science: states of matter, crystals and weather
You need
Devices with a browser (one per pair), a printed or projected Nakaya diagram, optional hand lenses and black card for real snow

Open Grow a Snowflake Jump to the quiz

Learning objectives

By the end of the lesson, students can:

Key vocabulary

Water vapour
Water as an invisible gas mixed into the air. Clouds are full of it, alongside tiny liquid droplets.
Deposition
A change of state straight from gas to solid, skipping the liquid. Frost and snow crystals grow this way.
Crystal
A solid whose particles are arranged in a regular, repeating pattern. In ordinary ice the pattern is hexagonal.
Humidity / supersaturation
How much water vapour the air holds. Supersaturated air holds more than it can keep as vapour, so the extra deposits onto ice.
Plate, column, dendrite
The three main families of snow crystal: flat hexagons, six-sided pencils, and branching stars with tree-like arms.
Symmetry
When a shape looks the same after it is turned or reflected. A snow crystal looks the same after a turn of 60°.

Background for the teacher

A snow crystal starts as a speck of ice, usually frozen onto a tiny dust particle, high in a cloud colder than about −10 °C. Water vapour then deposits directly onto it. Ice molecules link up by hydrogen bonds in rings of six, so the crystal begins as a tiny hexagonal prism. Its six corners poke further into the damp air than its faces, so they collect vapour faster and grow into arms; the arm tips branch for the same reason. All six arms grow at once in the same air, which is why they match.

Ukichiro Nakaya grew artificial snow in 1936 and mapped shape against conditions. Roughly: around −2 °C, thin plates; around −5 °C, columns and needles; from about −10 to −22 °C, plates again, becoming large stellar dendrites near −15 °C when the air is very humid; colder still, columns. Drier air always gives simpler, more compact shapes. A big snowflake holds about 1019 water molecules and falls at roughly 1 m/s, so it spends many minutes passing through different layers, and each layer adds its own ring of growth. The game simulates this with Reiter’s hexagonal cellular automaton; it is two-dimensional, so column weather barely widens the crystal on screen.

Warm-up (5 minutes)

Activity with the game

  1. Pairs open Grow a Snowflake and press Let it fall. For the first run, ignore the order and steer into just one colour of cloud for the whole fall. Note the colour and sketch the crystal on the mitten.
  2. Repeat for each colour: teal, blue, purple, pink and amber, plus one run kept in the clear dry gaps. Pairs build a table: cloud colour, shape grown, and the type name on the specimen card (for example P1e).
  3. Hand out the Nakaya diagram. Pairs match each cloud colour to a region of the diagram (temperature and humidity) and explain their reasoning, using the game’s notes if needed.
  4. Now fill an order. Read the sticky note’s three rings (centre, arms, tips) and plan a route before pressing Let it fall: which colour first, when to switch. Steer left and right (or use the arrow keys), catch the glowing vapour puffs and fight the gusts.
  5. Swap specimen cards with another pair without saying how they were grown. Each pair must “read” the crystal and write down the layers of air it fell through, centre outwards. Check against the grower’s route.
  6. Class round-up: whose field guide has the most types? Which crystal was hardest to grow, and why?

Discussion questions

Why does every arm of a snowflake look the same, if no arm “knows” what the others are doing?
Show a model answerAll six arms grow at the same time, in the same tiny pocket of air, at the same temperature and humidity. The same conditions produce the same growth, so the arms match without any communication.
Why do the corners of the hexagon grow faster than the flat faces?
Show a model answerThe corners stick out further into the surrounding damp air, so water vapour molecules reach them more easily. More vapour arriving means faster deposition, so the corners turn into arms.
If you caught a plate with long branching arms and flat plate tips, what weather did it fall through?
Show a model answerIt started in plate air (or dry air), passed through very humid air near −15 °C where the branches grew, and finished in drier or warmer air where only flat plate growth happened at the tips.
Are no two snowflakes really alike?
Show a model answerFor large, complex crystals, almost certainly: each holds around 1019 molecules and records a unique path through the cloud. Tiny simple prisms can look identical, and scientists have grown near-twins side by side in the lab.
Why does the crystal hardly grow in the amber column clouds in this game?
Show a model answerAround −5 °C real crystals grow lengthways into columns and needles. In the game the long axis points straight at you, and the model is flat, so from above the crystal barely gets wider.

Common misconceptions

Snowflakes are frozen raindrops.
Frozen raindrops are sleet or ice pellets. Snow crystals grow directly from water vapour by deposition, molecule by molecule.
The colder it is, the bigger and fancier the snowflakes.
The largest stellar dendrites form near −15 °C in very humid air. Much colder air holds less vapour, so crystals there are usually small plates and columns.
Snow is white because ice is white.
Ice is clear. Snow looks white because its many crystal faces scatter all colours of light in every direction.

Quick quiz

  1. What change of state builds a snow crystal?

    1. Liquid to solid (freezing)
    2. Gas to solid (deposition)
    3. Solid to gas (sublimation)
    4. Gas to liquid (condensation)
    Answer

    B. Water vapour deposits straight onto the ice without becoming liquid first.

  2. Why do snow crystals have six arms?

    1. Clouds are hexagonal
    2. Water molecules in ice join in rings of six
    3. Wind cuts them into six pieces
    4. Six is the most stable number of arms
    Answer

    B. The hexagonal arrangement of molecules in ice Ih gives the starting prism six corners, and each corner grows into an arm.

  3. Which conditions grow the biggest branching stars (stellar dendrites)?

    1. About −2 °C, dry air
    2. About −5 °C, dry air
    3. About −15 °C, very humid air
    4. About −30 °C, dry air
    Answer

    C. On the Nakaya diagram, dendrites appear near −15 °C when the air is strongly supersaturated.

  4. Around −5 °C, what shape do snow crystals tend to grow?

    1. Columns and needles
    2. Stellar dendrites
    3. Perfect spheres
    4. Thin plates only
    Answer

    A. The band around −4 to −10 °C favours growth along the crystal’s long axis, making columns and needles.

  5. A crystal has a plain hexagon centre and feathery arms. What can you say?

    1. It fell through one layer only
    2. Its centre grew in simpler air, then it met very humid dendrite air
    3. It melted and refroze
    4. It grew from the tips inwards
    Answer

    B. The centre grows first. Feathery arms show it later passed through humid air near −15 °C.

  6. Who took the first photograph of a single snow crystal, in 1885?

    1. Ukichiro Nakaya
    2. Kenneth Libbrecht
    3. Wilson Bentley
    4. Isaac Newton
    Answer

    C. Vermont farmer Wilson Bentley photographed one on 15 January 1885 and went on to photograph over 5,000.

Going further

Curriculum links

The science in this plan matches the notes and sources under Grow a Snowflake. Free to use and adapt for teaching. Ideas or corrections: hello@notebookfun.com.